#critlib: serving homeless library users
Storify of the #critlib chat from 2/16/2016 on serving homeless library users, moderated by @GinaMurrell1. For more information about #critlib, including past & future chats, please see http://critlib.org
- [The usual disclaimer: I tried to include all of Tweets from the chat and string Tweets from the same thread together as best as I could. Retweets, favorites, & tweets without the hashtag omitted on purpose. Lacunae, misreadings, or other mistakes my own.]
- Suggested readings:
- * “A home to the homeless” by Ellyn Ruhlmann, from American Libraries (2014)
- * “Not just a place to sleep: homeless perspectives on libraries in central Michigan” by Angie Kelleher, from Library Review (2013)
- Introductions
- Happy that so many of you are joining us for tonight's #critlib! First question is coming soon. All questions are at http://critlib.org/serving-homeless-library-users …
- @GinaMurrell1 I'm not a librarian but I'm into zine culture &volunteer at book collectives. Also spent undergrad sleepin in the lib #critlib
- I'm in @chrisalensula's Cmmnty Bldgg & Engmnt class (#LIScbe) rn, & we read abt this for class this week: http://bit.ly/1KoD2NC #critlib
- @AprilHathcock @fiiidget @chrisalensula Whenever I read "good old-fashioned common sense" I kind of want to . . . ugh. #critlib
- @bembrarian @AprilHathcock @fiiidget @chrisalensula Par for the course with that writer. All I've seen from him has been upsetting. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @bembrarian @AprilHathcock @fiiidget @chrisalensula that is awful. Also, "micturate"?.....? #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @bembrarian @AprilHathcock @fiiidget @chrisalensula Also, our library *is* a bathing facility - we have a shower! #critlib
- @whippersnapperQ Open whenever the library is open, it's a single unisex bathroom with a shower stall that locks & a changing table #critlib
- hi #critlib, student/archivist in Maryland, thinking on this as DC rolls out plan for network of homeless shelters https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-politics/homeless-shelters-to-be-spread-across-capital-under-plan-by-mayor-bowser/2016/02/09/318bc360-cf31-11e5-88cd-753e80cd29ad_story.html …
- Friend pointed to this piece earlier - another perspective on DC shelter plan http://www.citylab.com/cityfixer/2016/02/dc-homeless-shelter-network-bowser/462489/ … #critlib (sorry, on to Qs in a min)
- Q1. Does your library offer support services/outreach to homeless patrons?
- @davidjseleb Is this a FT resource #critlib
- @cuttingthecheez Yes, the manager is full time and will begin his work on March 7 #critlib
- A1. Our library welcomes and provides services to all but does not particularly reach out to the homeless. #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699778161689686016 …
- @bembrarian Interestingly, a work-study student was recently homeless & we supported him during his transition to find a home. #critlib
- @bembrarian I have heard of this happening in at least one other academic library. Probably happens a lot around campus. #critlib
- Yes! Is there any way to combat this? #critlib https://twitter.com/kellymce/status/699780469873750016 …
- .@kittenhumyn apparently in OR, you can get an ID w/a "descriptive address" but still a lot of barriers. #critlib http://www.oregon.gov/ODOT/DMV/pages/driverid/idproof.aspx#residence …
- @kittenhumyn Yes. Some libraries are allowing homeless patrons to use a shelter address when applying for a library card. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 @kittenhumyn we accept shelter addresses and corrections facilitiess for patrons at our public library (large system) #critlib
- @kittenhumyn at my mum’s library, patrons could present a letter from a shelter in lieu of driver’s license. Not perfect solution #critlib
- Public lib where I used to work also did this. & shelters/PO boxes wldn't count. I'd sign ppl up anyway. #critlib https://twitter.com/kellymce/status/699780469873750016 …
- Yes to signing up people w/out an address! Should be resistance-as-policy for undocumented people as well. #critlib https://twitter.com/AprilHathcock/status/699781453102628868 …
- +++ something all of our patrons should in theory be concerned about! #critlib https://twitter.com/colin_gpe/status/699782586088841216 …
- yes so let's extra not be like that. #critlib https://twitter.com/whippersnapperQ/status/699783677367209984 …
- @bembrarian Technically open but in prac don't get much neighb use, ID req to enter bldg w/lib = discourages (+ pub lib is nearby). #critlib
- @bembrarian Not the lib but the campus, we're w/in a bldg w/other uses. ID req is standard across CUNY afaik. #critlib
- @jessicahochman @bembrarian Yah, there's scanning in/signing in to get into all of the college buildings at MPOW. #critlib
- A1 Not to my knowledge...but there is also not a large homeless population in my town #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699778161689686016 …
- @thelizbrarian Agreed. Naperville initiative a triage approach based on who sees spectrum of community. @davidjseleb wise #critlib
- . @colin_gpe To be fair, I only pull late nights to work on my own finals. Maybe more lenient (no checks?) the rest of the time #critlib
- Q2. Does your library have policies that prohibit behaviors often associated with homelessness?
- @PoorCharlotte How are the homeless identified though? Is it a "warning" of the rules based upon appearance? #critlib
- @cuttingthecheez I believe they worked with the shelters and/or food kitchens on that #critlib
- @PoorCharlotte Curious to think about perceptions/prejudice re: homelessness as relating to substances and violence. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 My library has Rules of Behavior, but has tried to avoid rules that "prohibit homelessness" such as "no sleeping" #critlib
- A2 We're really open in our lib & haven't developed many antagonistic policies, except against noise & sex. #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699780430011064320 …
- @bembrarian @PoorCharlotte How does the general public, and how do inst. admin. define homelessness? What are defined stereotypes? #critlib
- @cuttingthecheez I'm reminded of the first season of Portlandia w/ the hide and seek legend who lives under the lib's stairs. #critlib
- In theory, #libraries are welcoming to all. Unfortunately, there are many policies keeping access from the homeless. #critlib
- @zinelib CITY of Naperville supported/paid 4 training to leverage. oak park library @davidjseleb took it on based in #community #critlib
- @sunnykins abbbb. sooo. luuuute. lyyyyy. #critlib
- Good Q. Esp given many homeless are ex-cons and most incarcerated are black and brown men. #critlib https://twitter.com/sunnykins/status/699782825298362368 …
- @ComposedCitrine Are babies allowed to sleep in the library? #critlib
- @ComposedCitrine seriously, especially at a uni library. There is no acad. library not constantly filled with people sleeping. #critlib
- Q3. What kind of staff training, if any, does the library provide in serving homeless patrons?
- A3. None. Though if there was an identified homeless population that used our lib., we would do training. #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699783073202745345 …
- @bembrarian Paradigm-wise, it seems like a lot of libs could be more proactive in identifying potential homeless using their lib. #critlib
- @bembrarian In a positive, service-providing way, of course. #critlib
- implicitly reinforcing negative stereotypes abt homelessness is crappy & dehumanizing & hurts everyone. >:( #critlib https://twitter.com/AprilHathcock/status/699783600380755968 …
- @AprilHathcock Oh jesus. #critlib
- @JessicaLColbert I'm fighting for the day when "disruptive patron"/"problem patron" gets stricken from the librarian vocab. #critlib
- @JessicaLColbert yikes. Anybody report that? #critlib
- @jessicahochman Yes. A group of us are working to change the videos used. #critlib
- @JessicaLColbert that's so awesome. Hey, #critlib could make better videos with a critical/culturally responsive perspective.
- @JessicaLColbert @jessicahochman That's in a ****ing video? It was deliberate & considered? My jaw's literally hanging open. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @jessicahochman Yes. Was originally used for RA training (homeless person in dorm). #critlib
- @JessicaLColbert @jessicahochman I won't type them here, but I'd have _words_ with whomever made these choices. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @jessicahochman First, I was mad a COP #acab was speaking to us about deescalation #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @jessicahochman And then some of us talked to HR about it, and the police chief agreed to have us work to change them #critlib
- @JessicaLColbert @foureyedsoul that's super cool; it's great you spoke up and real change is happening! #critlib
- @jessicahochman @JessicaLColbert Seriously. I'm impressed. Thank you for doing, especially as I assume it wasn't comfortable/easy. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @jessicahochman I think all three of us who spoke up also have mental illnesses, which was also in the training #critlib
- Key thing is that #communityinformatics informed @davidjseleb leadership w/@ComposedCitrine to respond to documented need. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 That's one of the objectives for our new manager, to determine the appropriate staff training needed #critlib
- @thelizbrarian Yes, I think "deescalation" is subjective in practice. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 Yes, trainings are important but smtms seen as delivered solution, rather than small step towards real respect & care #critlib
- @whippersnapperQ Respect & care - just treating the homeless as human beings - should be basic. Sadly, oftentimes it's not. #critlib
- @alegriarchivist Agreed. Where are these perceptions coming from? Is it systemic? Societal? #critlib
- @alegriarchivist Are there any open trainings like these available online? Would love to experience something so negative! #critlib
- @kittenhumyn if your library does have srvcs for homeless patrons, are they included in the brainstorming/planning in any way? #critlib
- A3: recently watched this webinar w/ staff http://bit.ly/1TpKnz1 our "challenging patrons" are rowdy kids not homeless #critlib
- Q4. What role should the library have in providing support services to homeless patrons?
- This is a great video lecture from a practitioner. A Librarian's Guide to Homelessness #critlib http://youtu.be/FYiEEhhrFh4
- @alsnyder02 Thanks for the resource! #critlib
- @alsnyder02 thanks for sharing this! #critlib
- . @AprilHathcock Seems hard (if worth it) to draw a line and know whether that line is about what's best for library, patrons, libs #critlib
- A4. I like the idea of being open/transparent re: providing the services, to positively influence others. #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699785444242825216 …
- @colin_gpe Partnership is key, gaining new perspectives. Being a leader but not the only leader. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 I see our role as part of broad community engagement, working with partners. Welcome, engage, identify, guide, refer. #critlib
- @bembrarian not to my knowledge, but I think a lot of that work is done quietly by diversity, VA, other offices #critlib
- @foureyedsoul @bembrarian Our whole advising system is borked. Campus initiative to fix it is in progress, but... #critlib
- library goals from #critlib: do better! https://twitter.com/kcrowe/status/699780524294983681 …
- protip: frame it as a service for bike commuters. :) #critlib https://twitter.com/hanamerino/status/699786877453344768 …
- This is a fantastic idea. Going to add it to my docket of things to do this week. :D Thank you! #critlib https://twitter.com/knsievert/status/699787129543503872 …
- @bembrarian digital safety means we are able to seek resources: health, financial etc without domestic violence perps' eyes #critlib
- @ComposedCitrine Good point. This is where diverse perspectives (including, ideally, representation from the homeless) helps. #critlib
- Q5. What can libraries do to better serve homeless patrons?
- @GinaMurrell1 I bet helping them to get ID would help #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 A5: Recognize them. #critlib
- @jessicahochman I did not know that! I am (too) often sleeping on the subway, but I'm sure I'm not who this is targeting! #critlib
- @jessicahochman Wow! Every NYer has fallen asleep on the subway (long day at work, drunk, lack of sleep, etc.) not just homeless. #critlib
- @jessicahochman Thumbs way down, CUNY students have told me they sleep while commuting on the subway (as we all do, right?). #critlib
- oh the incorrigible humanity... of librarians and our patrons. As it should be #critlib https://twitter.com/alsnyder02/status/699788424681803776 …
- A5. Great question. Simple & short, but: have more conversations. Be more mindful of what's not being done. #critlib https://twitter.com/GinaMurrell1/status/699788198063439877 …
- @bembrarian Yes, re: having conversations. Library can be space where homeless patrons can connect with dignity; creative programs. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul and "their" needs are *ours*. Seriously. Many are one step away from being there. Empathy key. #critlib
- @foureyedsoul all's good: I am behind you on how challenging our dichotomies are. Keep up the good fight! #critlib
- Also, sorry for tuning in late to #critlib. Looks like @GinaMurrell1 moderated a great chat!
- A5: always loved how @davidjseleb handled complaints abt homeless patrons. Forced others 2 acknowledge their humanity #critlib
- Yes. And then respect them. Don't be patronizng. Maybe they just want a DVD and don't want a social worker. #critlib https://twitter.com/JessicaLColbert/status/699788919257370625 …
- @AprilHathcock :nods: This speaks to how much even "progressive" convos about homelessness rely on stereotypes #critlib
- Wrapping up with thank yous & #critpitches!
- @GinaMurrell1 This was great! Thank YOU! I love having #critlib on the mind :)
- Thank you, @GinaMurrell1! GREAT topic, super lively and thoughtful discussion. #critlib
- @GinaMurrell1 #critlib talking about these topics can help bring changes to libraries, however small they may be!
- @alegriarchivist Hope to see you in a future #critlib. They get better and better!
- Great #critlib! Thanks @GinaMurrell1!
- @GinaMurrell1 Excellent #critlib! Gonna really start seeing how I can change things at my academic lib.
- Thanks @GinaMurrell1 & everyone for so much to think on. Good to be back #critlib
- Thanks @GinaMurrell1 great #critlib!
- .@GinaMurrell1 I can Storify. It's been a few months since the last time. Thanks for a really great chat! #critlib
- Such a terrific #critlib chat tonight, thanks so much @GinaMurrell1 and everyone!
- Hooray for @GinaMurrell1 for moderating an excellent #critlib!
- Here's my #critlib #critpitch: Some thoughts on IRB and vulnerable populations (like prisoners & homeless). https://aprilhathcock.wordpress.com/2016/02/16/some-of-the-trouble-with-irb/ …
- Catch stories now at #critlib on serving homeless library users @GinaMurrell1 steering. ALL #library workers WELCOME http://critlib.org/serving-homeless-library-users …
- thank you @GinaMurrell1 for moderating this discussion #critlib
- Super interested in this -- anyone do this combo? #critlib https://twitter.com/colin_gpe/status/699788839322161152 …
- @GinaMurrell1 You. Are. Awesome! Thank you! #critlib
- Sorry I missed #critlib; my #critpitch is that we in academia act on fact that some of our students+their families are homeless, hungry, etc
- And that we acknowledge that some of our staff are too bc wages are low and employment precarious. #critlib https://twitter.com/lisalibrarian/status/699792429948477441 …
- Thx @davidjseleb and @ComposedCitrine for fighting good fight. Walk the talk: it is all we can do #critlib
- Fin.